Mogul Maxxing / Blog / Decisions
01 · Decisions
How to decide what to work on first when everything feels important
The task that shouts loudest is rarely the one that moves the business. Here is what the research says about why urgency wins, why unfinished work follows you into the next task, and a simple rule for choosing your first task before the work window starts.

To decide what to work on first, pick the one task that moves your most important current goal forward and that only you can do, decide it before your work window starts, and write down when and where you'll begin. Then let urgent but low-value tasks wait until after that first block. Research on the "mere urgency effect" shows people tend to choose tasks with short deadlines over tasks with bigger payoffs, so the first task rarely chooses itself well in the moment. It needs a rule, made in advance.
The short answer
Choose your first task the evening before or at the end of your last work window, not at the start of the next one. Ask one question: which task, finished, would make the most difference to the thing that matters most this month? Check the payoff, not the deadline. Turn the answer into an if-then plan ("When I sit down at 8, I open the draft and write the offer page"). Close or park everything else in writing so it doesn't follow you in.
This is a return to the first Mogul Maxxing theme, decisions, with a narrower question. The decision fatigue article was about why the work window disappears before the work starts. The founder operating system piece was about deciding things once instead of every day. This article is about the single most repeated decision in a founder's week: what to do first.
I'm working on this in my own build. I have limited windows, more than one idea competing for them, and a first offer I'm validating in public. I'm not going to claim a method that's been proven in my business, because it hasn't been yet. What I can share is the research on why the choice goes wrong, the rule I'm testing, and the reasons behind each part of it.
Why deciding what to work on first is so hard
On paper, choosing a first task sounds trivial. You look at your list, pick the most important thing and start. In practice, the first minutes of a work window are where several forces collide.
First, there's the list itself. If you run a business, a creator brand or more than one project, the list is never short. Every item has a reason to be there. Second, some items have deadlines attached, even small ones: a reply someone is waiting for, a form that closes on Friday, a post you said you'd publish. Third, there's whatever you were doing before, still on your mind. And fourth, you're making the choice at exactly the moment you'd most like to be doing the work, which makes it tempting to grab whatever is nearest.
The result is a pattern most founders will recognize: the window starts, you clear a few quick things to "get them out of the way", and the important task gets the leftover time, or none. It isn't a character flaw. The research suggests it's a predictable way people choose under time pressure.
What the research says about choosing a first task
The mere urgency effect: deadlines beat payoffs
In a 2018 paper in the Journal of Consumer Research, Meng Zhu of Johns Hopkins University and her co-authors, Yang Yang and Christopher Hsee, described what they called the mere urgency effect. Across five experiments, participants chose between tasks, including a less important task with a short deadline and a more important one without one. People often picked the urgent, less valuable task, even when the other option was objectively better. As Zhu put it, people were "choosing objectively worse options over objectively better options".
Two details from the research matter for founders. The effect was stronger in people who saw themselves as generally busy. And reminding people of the payoffs of each task at the moment of choice reduced it. That second finding is the useful one: if urgency pulls attention toward the deadline, deliberately looking at the payoff pulls it back.
These were controlled experiments with simple tasks, not studies of founders running businesses, so it's worth not overstating them. But the direction is consistent with what many people notice in their own weeks: a small deadline can crowd out a large payoff.
Unfinished work follows you into the next task
Sophie Leroy's 2009 paper in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes introduced the term attention residue. In two experiments, she found that people performed better on a new task when they had stopped thinking about the previous one, and that leaving a task unfinished made it harder to shift attention. Interestingly, simply finishing the earlier task wasn't always enough on its own; time pressure while finishing it helped people disengage.
For choosing a first task, this cuts two ways. If you start your window by dipping into email or messages "just for a minute", you may carry that residue into the important work. And if yesterday ended mid-thought with no note about what comes next, that open loop may still be pulling at you when the window opens. I wrote more about switching costs in the multifaceted entrepreneur article; the short version is that the order of tasks affects how well you do each one.
A written plan can quiet the open loops
A 2011 paper by E. J. Masicampo and Roy Baumeister in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, titled "Consider it done!", tested what happens to unfinished goals. In their studies, unfulfilled goals produced intrusive thoughts and interfered with performance on an unrelated task, but making a specific plan for the unfinished goal reduced those effects, even though the goal itself was still not done.
Some caution is fair here. These were laboratory studies, and later research on related ideas, such as the much-cited Zeigarnik effect about memory for unfinished tasks, has produced mixed results. I'd treat this as a promising finding, not a settled law. But it supports a practical habit: you don't have to finish everything to clear your head before the first task. You have to decide, in writing, when each unfinished thing will be handled.
If-then plans help you start
Psychologists Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran published a meta-analysis in 2006 of research on implementation intentions: plans in the form "when situation X arises, I will do Y". Across 94 independent tests, forming implementation intentions had a medium-to-large effect on goal attainment (d = .65). The plans helped people get started, protect their efforts from distractions and move on from strategies that weren't working.
This is one of the better-supported findings in the psychology of goals, though as with any meta-analysis, the size of the effect varies across studies and settings. For a founder, the takeaway is concrete: "work on the offer tomorrow" is a wish. "When I sit down at 8:00, I open the offer document and write the outcome section" is a plan.
More options aren't always the problem
You'll often read that having too many choices paralyzes people, usually citing the famous jam study, in which shoppers offered a smaller selection of jams were more likely to buy one. The picture is more complicated than the popular version. A 2010 meta-analysis by Benjamin Scheibehenne, Rainer Greifeneder and Peter Todd, covering 63 conditions from 50 experiments, found a mean effect of choice overload that was virtually zero, with a lot of variation between studies. Choice overload seems to happen under some conditions, not as a general rule.
So a long to-do list isn't automatically what stops you. The more likely culprit is having no clear rule for choosing between items, which leaves you deciding from scratch every time, under the pull of whatever is most urgent.
We forget what the choice costs
Finally, research on opportunity cost neglect by Shane Frederick and colleagues, published in the Journal of Consumer Research in 2009, found that people often don't spontaneously think about what else they could do with their money when making a purchase; simply prompting them to consider alternatives changed their choices. The studies were about spending, not time, so the parallel is an analogy rather than evidence. But it's a useful one: every task you put first quietly displaces another, and unless you name what's being displaced, it's easy to ignore.
The Eisenhower matrix: useful, with a caveat
The best-known tool for this problem is the Eisenhower matrix, which sorts tasks into four boxes by urgency and importance. It's named after a line from President Dwight Eisenhower's 1954 address in Evanston, Illinois, in which he said he had two kinds of problems, the urgent and the important, and that the urgent ones were not important. According to research by Quote Investigator, Eisenhower attributed the idea to an unnamed former college president, and there's no evidence in his own record that he used a four-box grid; the matrix is a later popularization.
The origin story doesn't make the tool less useful. It's a good way to separate urgency from importance, which is exactly the confusion the mere urgency effect describes. Here's how the four boxes tend to look for a founder with limited windows.
| Box | Founder examples | What to do with it |
|---|---|---|
| Important and urgent | A client deliverable due tomorrow; a broken checkout page | Do it, but ask why it became urgent and fix the cause |
| Important, not urgent | Writing the offer; customer conversations; building the system that saves hours later | Protect it: this is usually where the first task belongs |
| Urgent, not important | Most messages; small requests; notifications | Batch after the first block, time-box, or hand off |
| Neither | Tweaking settings; reorganizing files; endless research | Drop it or park it on a someday list |
The caveat is that the matrix tells you which box a task belongs in, not which of several important tasks comes first. When three things are all important and none is urgent, you need a second filter. That's what the rule below is for.
Common prioritization methods compared
There are dozens of named methods. Most are variations on a few ideas. Here's how the common ones compare, and where each tends to help or fall short.
| Method | The idea | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eisenhower matrix | Sort by urgency and importance | Seeing that urgent and important are different | Doesn't rank tasks within the same box |
| "Eat the frog" | Do the hardest, most important task first (popularized by Brian Tracy; the Mark Twain attribution is doubtful) | Beating avoidance of a dreaded task | Hardest isn't always most valuable |
| Impact, confidence, ease scoring | Score each task on a few criteria and sort | Comparing many options at once | Scores can feel precise when they're guesses |
| One big, a few small | Plan one major task and a handful of minor ones per day | Keeping the list realistic | Still needs a rule for choosing the big one |
| The single-question filter | Ask which one task would make the others easier or unnecessary | Founders with limited windows | Requires knowing your current goal |
None of these has strong research behind it as a complete system; they're practical heuristics. What the research does support is the ingredients: separating payoff from deadline, deciding in advance, making an if-then plan, and closing open loops in writing. The rule I'm testing combines exactly those.
How to decide what to work on first: a five-step rule
This is the process I'm testing in the Mogul Maxxing build. It's designed to take about five minutes, at the end of one work window, so the next one starts with the decision already made.
1. Name the one goal that matters this month
You can't pick the most important task without knowing what it's important for. Write one sentence: the outcome that matters most for the business this month. For me, right now, that's moving my first offer through validation. If you run more than one project, this is the moment to choose which one is the anchor, as described in the multifaceted entrepreneur article. Without this sentence, every task can argue it's important.
2. List only the candidates that serve that goal
From your full list, pull out the two to five tasks that directly move that one goal. Everything else isn't deleted; it just isn't a candidate for the first block. This step does most of the work. It shrinks a list of thirty into a short list you can actually compare.
3. Compare payoffs, not deadlines
For each candidate, ask what changes if it's done. Because reminding people of payoffs reduced the mere urgency effect in the research, make the payoff explicit, even in a few words. Then use the single-question filter: which of these, once done, would make the others easier or unnecessary? That's usually your first task. If two are tied, use the tie-breakers in the next section.
The first-task check
- Goal: does it move the one thing that matters this month?
- Payoff: what's different once it's done, in one line?
- Leverage: does it make other tasks easier or unnecessary?
- Only you: is it something only you can do, or could it be delegated or automated?
- Fits the window: can a meaningful piece of it be done in one session?
4. Turn it into an if-then plan
Write the first task as an implementation intention: when and where you'll start, and the very first action. Not "work on the offer", but "When I sit down at 8:00 with coffee, I open the offer document and write the outcome paragraph." The first action should be small and physical, the kind of thing you can do without deciding anything else.
It also helps to leave the materials ready: the document open, the notes in one place. The point is to arrive at a task that's already begun, not a decision that's still waiting.
5. Park everything else in writing
Finally, give every other open loop a home: a time slot, a next step or a someday list. This is the practical version of the Masicampo and Baumeister finding. You're not finishing those tasks; you're deciding when they'll be handled so they're less likely to tug at you during the first block. A short line per item is enough.

Mogul Mastery · founding waitlist
Decision rules, built with founders
Mogul Mastery is the implementation program I'm building in public for founders with limited work windows: decision rules like this one, set up for your own business. It's in development and shaped by the people on the founding waitlist.
Tie-breakers when two tasks look equal
Sometimes the filter leaves two candidates that both seem right. Rather than deliberating, which eats the window, use a fixed tie-breaker. Decide which ones you'll use ahead of time, so the tie gets settled in seconds.
| Tie-breaker | Pick the task that… | Why it helps |
|---|---|---|
| Blocks others | Someone else is waiting on before they can start | Unblocking multiplies progress beyond your own window |
| Reduces uncertainty | Answers a question the rest of the plan depends on | Saves work that might otherwise be wasted |
| Needs your best attention | Requires deep thinking rather than routine execution | Use the freshest part of the window for the hardest thinking |
| Has been avoided | You've postponed more than once | Avoided tasks tend to grow; naming them first breaks the pattern |
| Is smaller | Can actually be finished in this window | A finished task leaves less residue than a half-done one |
You don't need all five. Pick two that fit how you work and use them in order. The goal is to stop the tie from becoming its own decision.
What to do with the urgent things
Choosing an important first task doesn't make urgent tasks disappear. Clients still need replies, and some deadlines are real. The aim is to put them in their place, not ignore them.
- Check for true emergencies first, briefly. If something is genuinely on fire, such as a payment failing or a client deliverable due today, it is important and urgent, and it goes first. Make this a quick scan, not a dive into the inbox.
- Batch the rest after the first block. Most messages can wait an hour or two. Handle them together, with a time limit.
- Ask why it's urgent. Recurring urgency is often a missing system: a template, a clearer expectation with a client, a deadline set too tight. Fixing the cause is itself an important, non-urgent task.
- Delegate or automate where you can. Urgent but unimportant work is the best candidate to hand off, as covered in the founder operating system article.

Common mistakes when deciding what to work on first
Deciding at the start of the window
This is the most common one. If the decision happens when the window opens, it competes with every notification and every quick task. Move it to the end of the previous window, when you have the most context about where things stand.
Clearing small tasks "to get them out of the way"
It feels productive, and sometimes it is. But it often spends the window's best attention on the least valuable work, and it can leave attention residue from all those small switches. If quick tasks matter, batch them after the first block.
Choosing the most urgent instead of the most valuable
That's the mere urgency effect at work. The fix from the research is simple: say the payoff out loud, or write it down, before you choose.
Picking a first task that's too big
"Build the course" isn't a first task; it's a project. Choose a piece that can be meaningfully advanced in one session, with a clear first action.
Changing the decision mid-window
Unless something genuinely urgent and important comes up, stick with the plan. Re-deciding in the middle of the window brings back exactly the deliberation the rule was meant to remove.
Having no goal to measure against
If you skip step one, every task looks important. The monthly goal is what makes the comparison possible.
How AI can help, and where it shouldn't
An AI second brain can make this five-minute decision faster. Paste in your monthly goal and your open task list, and ask it to group tasks by which goal they serve, flag which ones have real deadlines, and draft an if-then plan for the task you choose. It can also keep a running list of parked loops so they're out of your head.
What it shouldn't do is make the choice for you. It doesn't know your business the way you do, and the judgment about what matters most is precisely the part worth keeping. Use it to organize the options and remember the context; make the call yourself. I'm testing this in the build, and I'll share what holds up.
Frequently asked questions
How do I decide what to work on first?
Pick the one task that moves your most important current goal forward, that only you can do, and that would make other tasks easier once done. Decide it before your work window starts, write down when and where you'll begin, and let urgent but low-value tasks wait until after that first block.
What is the mere urgency effect?
It is the tendency, described by Meng Zhu, Yang Yang and Christopher Hsee in a 2018 Journal of Consumer Research paper, for people to choose tasks with short deadlines over more important tasks with larger payoffs. Reminding people of the payoffs at the moment of choice reduced the effect in their experiments.
Should I do the hardest task first?
Not necessarily. Doing a dreaded task first can help if you tend to avoid it, but the hardest task is not always the most valuable one. A better test is which task, once done, would make the most difference to your current goal.
Does the Eisenhower matrix actually work?
It is a useful way to separate urgency from importance, which addresses a real bias in how people choose tasks. There is little direct research on the matrix itself, and it does not rank tasks that fall in the same box, so it works best combined with a rule for choosing among important tasks.
When is the best time to decide what to work on first?
At the end of your previous work window or the evening before. You have the most context then, and deciding in advance means the next window starts with work rather than with a decision that competes with every notification.
What is an implementation intention?
An implementation intention is an if-then plan that links a situation to an action, such as when I sit down at 8 I will open the offer document and write the outcome section. A 2006 meta-analysis by Gollwitzer and Sheeran of 94 tests found a medium-to-large effect on goal attainment.
Should I answer email before starting my most important task?
Usually not, beyond a brief scan for genuine emergencies. Research on attention residue suggests that switching into a new task while still thinking about the previous one can hurt performance, so batching messages after your first focused block tends to protect it.
Is having too many tasks what causes procrastination?
Not by itself. A 2010 meta-analysis of choice overload found an average effect close to zero, with large variation between studies. Having no clear rule for choosing between tasks is often the bigger problem than the number of tasks.
What if two tasks seem equally important?
Use a tie-breaker you decided in advance, for example the task that unblocks someone else, the one that answers a question the rest of the plan depends on, or the one you have avoided more than once. The goal is to settle the tie in seconds instead of deliberating.
Where this goes next
This article goes deeper inside the decisions theme that started with decision fatigue for entrepreneurs. Next in the series: what an AI second brain should actually do for a founder, a plan for using AI inside a 60-minute work window, and the difference between a tool, a workflow and a business system. If you're choosing between projects rather than tasks, start with the multifaceted entrepreneur article; if your first task right now is testing an idea, the offer validation guide and the creator-to-founder piece are the natural next reads.
To get each new article as it's published, join the Mogul Movement. If you'd like decision rules like these built into your own business, the Mogul Mastery founding waitlist is open. You can browse every article on the Mogul Maxxing blog, or go back to the homepage for the full series.
Sources
- Zhu, M., Yang, Y., & Hsee, C. K. (2018). The mere urgency effect. Journal of Consumer Research, 45(3), 673–690. Summary: Johns Hopkins University Hub.
- Leroy, S. (2009). Why is it so hard to do my work? The challenge of attention residue when switching between work tasks. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 109(2), 168–181.
- Masicampo, E. J., & Baumeister, R. F. (2011). Consider it done! Plan making can eliminate the cognitive effects of unfulfilled goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 101(4), 667–683.
- Gollwitzer, P. M., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69–119.
- Scheibehenne, B., Greifeneder, R., & Todd, P. M. (2010). Can there ever be too many options? A meta-analytic review of choice overload. Journal of Consumer Research, 37(3), 409–425.
- Frederick, S., Novemsky, N., Wang, J., Dhar, R., & Nowlis, S. (2009). Opportunity cost neglect. Journal of Consumer Research, 36(4), 553–561.
- Quote Investigator (2014). What is important is seldom urgent and what is urgent is seldom important.
This article is general information about research on decision making and common productivity practices, not professional, medical or financial advice. Study findings describe averages in specific settings and may not apply the same way to every person or business.